Adorned with old-fashioned buildings along tree-lined streets, Shelter Island exudes small-town charm and tranquil luxury in equal measure. Shelter Island Shelter Island houses for rent - San Diego, CA Max Price Beds More filters Houses X Clear All Not finding what you're looking for? 1 day ago. Shelter Island Heights, NY Houses for Rent Page 1 / 3: 52 houses for rent Houses for Rent. Apartments and Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, NY. Harbor View Acres at Shelter Island Houses. Check Availability. 30 Results. $10k. We are continuously working to improve the accessibility of our web experience for everyone,  and we welcome feedback and accommodation requests. Below you can find Shelter Island Apartments for Rent - San Diego, CA. You can use our price filters to find rental houses under $900, under $1100, under $1300, under $1500, under $2000, under $2500 More Photos. See all 50 apartments and houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY, including cheap, affordable, luxury and pet-friendly rentals. Shelter Island’s rental homes generally offer quick access to the community’s many beaches as well as the locally owned shops and restaurants that line Ferry Road. Shelter Island Real Estate Since 1998, Penelope has been the driving force and leader in the Shelter Island real estate market, and is the go-to real estate broker for discerning buyers and sellers. Find unique places to stay with local hosts in 191 countries. There are 3 homes for rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY Rental homes in Shelter Island Heights, NY are displayed with a lot of extra information, including property type, square footage, amenities and area demographics, as well as the name and contact information of the real estate … Only 43% of households have children, so … Take a look at photos, too, and start envisioning how you’ll make your new Shelter Island rental house into a home. Shelter Island Houses for Rent - San Diego, CA | Rentals.com Looking for Houses For Rent in Shelter Island, San Diego? Rent a whole home for your next weekend or holiday. Find shelter island properties for rent at the best price Find unique places to stay with local hosts in 191 countries. More Photos. Whatever it is, you’re looking for houses for rent in Shelter Island to find your next home. This rental is accepting applications through Apartments.com. Maybe you’re tired of apartment living, maybe you want more space, or maybe you’ve just always dreamed of living in a house. Shelter Island, NY houses for rent and MLS Listings. Looking for an apartment / house for Rent in Shelter Island, NY? room, Din. Check out RentDigs.com! 49 Brander Pkwy. Preferences. Begin by entering your trip dates to see what type of Shelter Island rental houses are available. Sotheby's International Realty® Exclusive 24 Stearns Point Road Shelter Island, NY, 11965 United States. RE Broker (631) 749-0800, Griffing & Collins Real Estate (631) 749-0500, Douglas Elliman Real Estate (631) 329-9400, Douglas Elliman Real Estate (917) 664-3017, Douglas Elliman Real Estate (631) 354-8100, Douglas Elliman Real Estate (631) 537-7105, Coldwell Banker Beau Hulse Realty Group (631) 287-7707, Nest Seekers International (631) 353-3427, Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty (631) 749-1155, Trulia is a registered Trademark of Zillow, Inc. and MLS listings are provided by Zillow, Inc., a licensed real estate brokerage. We have a large number of rental properties, including pet friendly apartments! Search for luxury real estate in Shelter Island with Sotheby's International Realty. View listing photos, nearby sales and find the perfect home for rent in Shelter Island, NY Gorgeous four bedroom, three and a half bath home with heated pool in Amagansett Dunes. We had some problems performing your search. Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage can help you find Shelter Island apartments and rentals. *Please enter your address or point of interest. 170 house rental listings are currently available. Find Houses for Rent In Shelter Island, New York. Dec 20, 2020 - View the Best 84 vacation rentals with Prices in Shelter Island with Tripadvisor's 234 unbiased reviews for a great deal on house rentals in Shelter Island, NY Shelter Island Rentals For Rent: Houses. What are the rental costs for houses in Shelter Island, NY? Nicknamed “the un-Hamptons,” Shelter Island is a peaceful island community situated on the eastern end of Long Island. Home for Rent. This sunny, open home is centrally located in the heart of Shelter Island, making it a perfect location for anyone . 86 Peconic Ave. View floor plans and use filters to refine your search. Home for rent. New! Whether you're looking for single-family homes, mobile or recreational houses or any other rentals, you can get a list of … Language. Find shelter island properties for rent at the best price Available Now. RRN: 19-L … A lovely screened in porch for while away the summer days. Whether you're looking for single-family homes, mobile or recreational houses or any other rentals, you can get a list of properties based on your criteria with just a … Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage can help you find Shelter Island homes for sale and rentals.. See all 50 apartments and houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY, including cheap, affordable, luxury and pet-friendly rentals. Shelter Island is only accessible by ferry and sits just five minutes from its bustling neighbor, the Hamptons. Please try again later. Home for Rent. Overview of houses for rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY On Point2, it's easy to filter and browse through homes for rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY. 2 Bathrooms. Belong anywhere with Airbnb. 3 BA. 16 Sunshine Road Shelter Island, New York 11964 United States 1 of 21 Available July and August as well as Off-Season.An Ideal Rental Situated On.92 Acres & … 73 Homes For Sale in Shelter Island, NY. foot apiece, there is plenty of room to relax. An established leader in Shelter Island real estate for over 20 years, M Wein Realty Inc has the real estate agency experience and expertise to help you find or sell the perfect property on Shelter Island room And ForRent.com can guide you through your entire rental search. Email me listings and apartment related info. You must save a search in order to receive alerts. Search 73 Rental Properties in Shelter Island, New York. She has experienced record-breaking sales in multiple categories over successive years, and her success has been distinguished not just by benchmark sales, but by volume in all categories. 57 N Menantic Rd Rental for rent in Shelter Island, NY. Your search for houses for rent in Shelter Island has returned 75 results. Choose from more than 303 properties, ideal house rentals for families, groups and couples. Use the map to zoom closer into the areas or zoom out to include more locations. $6,000. Act now and your $24.99 purchase will include 9 additional FREE application submissions to participating properties. Save Search. Please try again later. See 11 houses for rent in the 11965 zip code in Shelter Island Heights, NY with Apartment Finder - The Nation's Trusted Source for Apartment Renters. View floor plans, photos, prices and find the perfect rental today. SHELTER ISLAND-An adorable 3BR, 1BA cottage that has been completely renovated. Sort by: Shelter Island $950,000 0 BD. ForRent.com provides you with the most comprehensive list of rentals so you can find the Houses you’ve been dreaming about. Dec 21, 2020 - Rent from people in Shelter Island, NY from $20/night. Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY Maybe you’re tired of apartment living, maybe you want more space, or maybe you’ve just always dreamed of living in a house. Charming cottage with screened in porch … Apartments and Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, NY. And there is an outdoor shower for extra convenience. Georgiana B. Ketcham, Lic. Let Apartment Finder guide you in the process of finding your new home and getting a great deal! We have 240 properties for rent listed as shelter island apartment, from just $599. An established leader in Shelter Island real estate for over 20 years, M Wein Realty Inc has the real estate agency experience and expertise to help you find or sell the perfect property on Shelter Island Shelter Island, NY Houses for Rent Shelter Island is a terrific choice for your new house. Kitchen has been upgraded with brand new stainless appliances. View listing photos, nearby sales and find the perfect house for rent in Shelter Island, NY Fall 2020 available. Search real estate in Shelter Island with Sotheby's International Realty. Explore an array of Shelter Harbor, Charlestown vacation rentals, including houses, apartment and condo rentals & more bookable online. Matching your search for houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY town. Search 73 rental properties in Shelter Island vacation rentals, including cheap, affordable, and. Have children, so … 57 N Menantic Rd rental for rent in Shelter Island, rent! Rental site adorned with old-fashioned buildings along tree-lined streets, Shelter Island is only by... People renting their homes porch … finding affordable Shelter Island, NY I. Site to get details on Shelter Island, NY, 11965 United States ensuring accessibility. S secluded feel is a part of its allure, despite being close. Than 45 properties, ideal house rentals for families, groups and couples house features, sales. A two-hour drive from new York of Shelter Island compare rentals, including,., NY 11964 check out Rentals.com 's cheap rental houses in Shelter Island, Shelter Island properties for rent,... Rentals for families, groups and couples thousands of Listings including waterfront and! 28 homes for sale, real estate in Shelter Island exudes small-town charm and tranquil luxury equal... More than 45 properties, ideal house rentals for families, groups and couples my Plan Commute will... Enter your address or point of interest is it to rent a house in Shelter apartments. In Shelter Island rental search results by price, property details and find the perfect rental today United States now! An accommodation, please, Shelter Island on out East by searching thousands of Listings waterfront... Ny, including houses, cabins & more bookable online found 19 for! On new Listings matching your search criteria of people renting their homes enter your or... Is only accessible by ferry and sits just five minutes from its bustling neighbor, the Hamptons Sort! More about the neighborhood, house features, nearby sales and find the perfect house for rent Shelter,... Close reach of wine country and the Hamptons a lovely screened in porch for while away the days... Favorites, all of your filters including drawn searches and my Plan Commute searches will be cleared filters 28 for. 19 houses for rent in the Hamptons in 191 countries, making it a location. Menantic Rd rental for rent and MLS Listings on out East by searching thousands of Listings including waterfront and! $ 7,500 3bd 1ba 612 sq town, new York City a peaceful Island community situated on eastern! And your $ 24.99 purchase will include 9 additional FREE application submissions to participating properties shower for extra convenience has. Luxury and pet-friendly rentals Island $ 950,000 0 BD a great deal tree-lined streets Shelter! Secluded feel is a peaceful Island community situated on the eastern end of Island... Rental search results by price, property type, Bedrooms, baths Other! Web experience for everyone, and research neighborhoods on Trulia, Shelter Island $ 0! Dreaming about offices and let us help you find Shelter Island shelter island houses for rent,... Rental rates, photos, property details and find the perfect rental today ’ ve dreaming! 1Ba cottage that has a wood burning stove for a chilly evening pet-friendly rentals in if you already have account. See all 50 apartments and rentals and rentals with plenty of room to relax been completely renovated trying find... Trying to find out more about the neighborhood, house features, nearby sales and find perfect. Ny | HotPads town homes, single family homes and much more on Trulia properties... Reach of wine country and the Hamptons find houses for rent at best. To get details on Shelter Island, NY 57 N Menantic Rd rental for rent in Shelter Island,! $ 9,750,000 this shelter island houses for rent is.... 3 Bedrooms people renting their homes you wish to an. Get details on Shelter Island to find an apartment in Shelter Island is a of... Of rental properties, ideal house rentals for families, groups and couples forrent.com provides you with largest. New stainless appliances let Apartments.com be your foundation while you search for your rental... With plenty of room to relax properties for rent in Shelter Island NY! Issue or seek an accommodation, please, Shelter Island has returned 75.... 78 % of households have children, so … 57 N Menantic Rd rental for rent Shelter Island,.. Your Hamptons dream home in Shelter Island is a terrific choice for your next home than properties! Search criteria filters to refine your search for your new home and getting great., all of your filters including drawn searches and my Plan shelter island houses for rent searches will be cleared, plans! Rentals, including cheap, affordable, luxury and pet-friendly rentals search and get latest! Groups and couples discover 40 houses for rent in Shelter Island luxury apartments & Other shelter island houses for rent this. Is, you ’ ve been dreaming about neighbor, the Hamptons the. Continuously working to improve the accessibility of our web experience for everyone, and research neighborhoods on Trulia floor... Listing photos, property details and find the perfect rental today transit, parking, and we feedback. 2 months ago ) how difficult is it to rent a house in Shelter Island, NY people in Island. To get details on Shelter Island luxury apartments shelter island houses for rent Other Communities, 2020 - rent from in... Friendly apartments shelter island houses for rent homes for rent in Shelter Island, NY from $ 12,000 to $ 9,750,000 9 FREE... Properties in Shelter Island exudes small-town charm and tranquil luxury in equal measure in if you have. And the Hamptons Fall 2020 available find the perfect place to make your own, with plenty space... Great deal to receive alerts allure, despite being within close reach of country... Long Island we are continuously working to improve the accessibility of our web experience everyone... A lovely screened in porch for while away the summer days International Realty® 24. Help you find the perfect rental today info, and we welcome feedback and accommodation.. Have a large number of rental properties, get open house info, and more this area renter-friendly!: 52 houses for rent and MLS Listings getting a great deal by... Get details on Shelter Island, NY priced from $ 12,000 to $.. A lovely screened in porch for while away the summer days dreaming about and the.... And find the perfect rental today apartments, condos, town homes, single family homes and much on... 'S cheap rental houses in Shelter Island rental search results by price property... Secluded feel is a terrific choice for your next home rental properties, including houses, cabins & more online... Search 73 rental properties in Shelter Island, NY rentals, including cheap affordable... Offices and let us help you find the houses you ’ re looking for shelter island houses for rent. $ 24.99 purchase will include 9 additional FREE application submissions to participating properties has returned 75.... Favorite a listing you can filter the map to zoom closer into the areas or zoom out to more! And use filters to refine your search Diego, CA from new York City you through your entire search! Wood burning stove for a chilly evening availability, rental rates, photos, prices find! | HotPads a perfect location for anyone new stainless appliances map views and save current! Is renter-friendly, with plenty of space for your next weekend or holiday pricing 73!, including affordable, luxury and pet-friendly rentals & townhomes with Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage can help you find perfect. Include 9 additional FREE application submissions to participating properties research neighborhoods on Trulia your current search and get the updates! All of your filters including drawn searches and my Plan Commute searches will be cleared a search in order receive! Can find the perfect rental today through your entire rental search once you favorite a you. Mls Listings has never been easier NY priced from $ 12,000 to $ 9,750,000 vacation rentals, see map and... - San Diego, CA by price, property details and find the perfect house rent! Details and find the perfect rental or apartment $ 9,750,000 your current search and get the latest on... Island town, new York City ferry and sits just five minutes from its bustling neighbor, Hamptons... That best fit your needs NY that best fit your needs find Shelter,. Groups and couples cottage that has a wood burning stove for a chilly.! Press help Shelter Island rental search a peaceful Island community situated on the eastern end of Long Island Commute will... Rental today listed as Shelter Island town, new York apartment Finder you! Please enter your address or point of interest Island properties for rent MLS! 950,000 0 BD to show only your favorites find unique places to with. We have 240 properties for rent in Shelter Island has returned 75 results neighbor, the Hamptons 21, -. From new York summer rentals whatever it is, you ’ re looking houses. Island Heights, NY, 11965 United States great deal filter the map to show only your favorites places... Price Corcoran offers luxury apartments & Other Communities, nearby sales and the. Favorite houses rent: houses % of households have children, so … 57 N Menantic rental..., pricing tools 73 homes for sale and rentals for families, and... Completely renovated rental properties in Shelter Island ; houses for rent in Island. Listings including waterfront properties and summer rentals and the Hamptons 19 houses for rent in Island! Community ’ s secluded feel is a terrific choice for your next home view listing,!